Early Tissue Patterning Recreated by Mouse Embryonic Fibroblasts in a Three-Dimensional Environment
Abstract
Cellular self-organization studies have been mainly focused on models such as Volvox, the slime mold Dictyostelium discoideum, and animal (metazoan) embryos. Moreover, animal tissues undergoing regeneration also exhibit properties of embryonic systems such as the self-organization process that rebuilds tissue complexity and function. We speculated that the recreation in vitro of the biological, biophysical, and biomechanical conditions similar to those of a regenerative milieu could elicit the intrinsic capacity of differentiated cells to proceed to the development of a tissue-like structure. Here we show that, when primary mouse embryonic fibroblasts are cultured in a soft nanofiber scaffold, they establish a cellular network that causes an organized cell contraction, proliferation, and migration that ends in the formation of a symmetrically bilateral structure with a distinct central axis. A subset of mesodermal genes (brachyury, Sox9,Runx2) is upregulated during this morphogenetic process. The expression of brachyury was localized first at the central axis, extending then to both sides of the structure. The spontaneous formation of cartilage-like tissue mainly at the paraxial zone followed expression of Sox9 and Runx2. Because cellular self-organization is an intrinsic property of the tissues undergoing development, this model could lead to new ways to consider tissue engineering and regenerative medicine.
Introduction
The self-assembling peptide RAD16-I, which forms promising three-dimensional (3D) scaffolds for tissue-engineering applications, has been used to promote growth and proliferation of multiple cell types, including chondrocytes, hepatocytes, endothelial cells, osteoblasts, and neuronal cells, as well as embryonic and somatic stem cells.11–18 In a recent work, we demonstrated that, after culturing primary mouse embryonic fibroblasts (MEFs) into a th3D self-assembling peptide scaffold for several days, they up-regulated osteopontin (OPN) and two metalloproteinases (MMP-2 and MMP-9), known as type IV and V collagenases or the 72-kDa gelatinase A and
The in vitro cellular system we describe here undergoes a process that resembles many aspects of animal development, including cell aggregation, proliferation, migration, and tissue specification and, most importantly, morphogenesis and pattern formation.
Materials and Methods
Culture of MEFs
MEFs isolated from C57BL/6 embryos at day 14 were purchased from the American Type Culture Collection (scrc-1008; ATCC, Manassas, VA). These fibroblasts (<9th passage) were cultured in 75- or 175-cm2 flasks in fibroblast medium (FM), which contains high-glucose Dulbecco's modified Eagle medium (DMEM; 15-013-CV; Mediatech, Manassas, VA) supplemented with 15% (v/v) fetal bovine serum (FBS; 14-501F, Lonza, Allendale, NJ), 4 mM L-glutamine (82007-322, VWR, West Chester, PA), 100 μM minimum essential medium non-essential amino acids (11140-050, Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA), 100 U/mL penicillin, and 0.1 mg/mL streptomycin (20001, JR Scientific, Woodland, CA). In some cases, the medium was supplemented with 10 to 20 nM of insulin-like growth factor (IGF)-I (I8779 Sigma-Aldrich, St Louis, MO) and 1 to 20 nM of platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF)-BB (recombinant protein from rat, P4056 Sigma-Aldrich).
3D culture technique
For experiments with RAD16-I, MEFs (<9th passage) were trypsinized from the culture flasks, suspended in 20% sucrose (S0389, Sigma-Aldrich). Commercial 1% RAD16-I (Puramatrix, Becton & Dickinson, Franklin Lakes, NJ) was diluted with water to obtain a solution of 0.5% RAD16-I. Then equal volumes of the cell suspension in 20% sucrose and RAD16-I (1% or 0.5%) were mixed to render a final cell suspension containing 2 × 106 MEFs/mL, 10% sucrose, and either 0.25% or 0.5% of RAD16-I. Alternatively, freshly isolated MEFs were suspended in 10% sucrose and mixed with 0.5% RAD16-I in 10% sucrose, to obtain a final MEF concentration of 2 × 106cells/mL, 10% sucrose, and 0.25% RAD16-I. This suspension (80 μL) containing cells and RAD16-I was loaded into 9-mm-diameter cell culture inserts (PICM01250, Millipore, Billerica, MA) previously placed inside 6-well culture plates (Nunc, Rochester, NY). Then 500 μL of FM was added to the wells, outside the inserts. The medium penetrates the insert from the bottom membrane, inducing a bottom-to-top self-assembly of RAD16-I and thus the formation of a gel with MEFs suspended inside the scaffold. After the gel was formed, 500 μL of FM was added on top of the hydrogel. The FM flows trough the gel, washing out the remaining sucrose (Fig. 1A). This step was repeated two more times. Finally, 500 μL of FM was loaded inside the insert and 2.5 mL of FM in the well outside the insert. Incubation was performed at 37°C with 5% carbon dioxide, and medium was changed every 2 days.
FIG. 1. Morphogenetic changes of mouse embryonic fibroblasts (MEFs) in three-dimensional (3D) cultures. (A) Scheme of a MEF culture and differentiation protocol. (B) MEFs were cultured using two different concentrations of RAD16-I to form hydrogels with different stiffness. They were cultured with three different concentrations of FBS in the fibroblast medium (FM) formulation. Rate of contraction was observed for each combination of fetal bovine serum percentage and RAD16-I concentration at day 10. Results are presented qualitatively in the table. (C) Main morphological process observed using visual inspection of MEFs cultured with FM in RAD16-I 0.25%. The figure shows the contraction of MEFs in the hydrogel. In 7 to 10 days a 9-mm-diameter hydrogel disk becomes a compact tissue-like cell mass of approximately 2 × 4 mm with bilateral patterning. Optical cross-sections depict the presence of an internal cavity. Asterisks at both sides of the structure indicate the zone of lateral contraction forces. (D) A model indicating the main morphological processes is presented as a guide to help understand the development of the 3D bilateral structure. The asterisks also indicate the zone of lateral force generation and the presence of a cavity developed during the morphological process and the empty cavity present in the structure. (E) Inhibition of the 3D bilateral structure development by cell cycle arrest induced by staurosporine. MEFs were incubated with and without staurosporine (20 nM) for 7 days. Proliferation was studied using a bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) pulse followed by immunostaining against BrdU. Asterisk shows a close-up of the positively stained MEFs. Bar = 500 μm. (F) MEFs were incubated for 14 days with different concentrations of staurosporine (0, 2, 20 nM) to further analyze the effect of proliferation in the contraction phenomenon. Bar = 500 μm. Color images available online at www.liebertonline.com/ten.
For the experiments with agarose, the same cells were suspended in FM. This cell suspension was mixed with an equal volume of 0.5% Omnipur agarose (EM Science, Gibbstown, NJ) in 10% sucrose (S0389, Sigma-Aldrich) to obtain a final cell density of 2 × 106 cells/mL in 0.25% agarose. The cell suspension was briefly cooled until the agarose rendered the gels, which were then equilibrated in FM and incubated as described above.
For the experiments with collagen type I, the same cells were suspended in FM. Isotonic collagen 0.4% was prepared by diluting commercial collagen type I (354236, Becton & Dickinson) with filtered 10× phosphate buffered saline (PBS; 14040, Invitrogen) and sterile water (Mediatech). This solution was neutralized with sterile 1 M sodium hydroxide (Sigma-Aldrich) using phenol red (P4633, Sigma-Aldrich) as an indicator. Imediately after neutralization, equal volumes of the freshly prepared collagen solution and the cell suspension were mixed, to obtain a final cell density of 2 × 106 cells/mL in 0.2% collagen, and poured inside cell culture inserts. The suspension was heated at 37°C so that the collagen fibers formed a gel inside the inserts. Gels were cultured in FM and incubated as described above.
Differentiation assays
MEFs were cultured in the 3D hydrogels with FM for 12 days, and after that, medium was changed to differentiation medium. MEFs were maintained in differentiation medium for 21 days. As controls, MEFs were cultured for 33 days in regular fibroblast medium. For osteogenic differentiation, the medium was high-glucose DMEM with 10% FBS, 1% (v/v) penicillin streptomycin, and 4 mM L-glutamine supplemented with Lonza's osteogenic factors: 0.05 mM ascorbate, 10 mM β-glycerophosphate, 0.1 μM dexamethasone, and 20 nM 1α,25-(OH)2 vitamin D3 (PT-3002, Lonza).
The medium to induce chondrogenic differentiation was provided by Cambrex (Charles City, IA) and contained basal medium supplemented with R3-IGF, transforming growth factor beta (TGF)-β, insulin, transferrin, FBS, and gentamycin/amphotericin. The concentrations of the supplements were not available from the manufacturer.
For the adipogenic differentiation, the medium was DMEM with 10% FBS, 8 μg/mL biotin, 4 μg/mL pantothenate (C8731, Sigma-Aldrich), 0.5 mM 3-isobutyl-1-methylxanthine (I7018, Sigma-Aldrich), 1 μM dexamethasone (PT-3002, Lonza), and 10 μg/mL insulin (CC-4182, Lonza).
Antibodies
Anti-digoxigenin (DIG) sheep polyclonal antibody (11333089001) was purchased from Roche Diagnostics (Indianapolis, IN). All other antibodies were purchased from Santa Cruz Biotechnology (Santa Cruz, CA). Anti-collagen type II (sc7764), anti-brachyury (sc17743), anti-nestin (sc21248), and anti-actin (sc1615) goat polyclonal antibodies and anti-PEBP2αA (sc10758; also known as anti-Runx2) and anti-Sox9 rabbit polyclonal antibodies were used as primary antibodies. Anti-sheep (sc2473), anti-goat (sc2020), and anti-rabbit (sc2317) donkey antibodies horseradish peroxidase (HRP)-conjugated and fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC)-labeled chicken anti-goat (sc2988) antibodies were used as secondary antibodies.
Cell-cycle arrest assays with staurosporine
Cultures of MEFs were incubated in FM with 20 nM staurosporine (569397, Calbiochem, Gibbstown, NJ) for 7 days while controls were incubated in FM. At day 6, a pulse of bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) was applied overnight (16 h). MEFs were fixed at day 7 and stained with an anti-BrdU FITC-conjugated mouse monoclonal antibody immunoglobulin G 1 (Becton, Dickinson and Company). To assess the dose-response effect of staurosporine on MEFs, these were incubated with different concentrations of staurosporine (0, 2, 20 nM) for 14 days. The cell mass contraction was visually inspected during these 14 days.
Phenotype assignment
To assign osteoblastic, chondrogenic, or adipogenic phenotypes, we stained for specific elements of each phenotype. MEFs underwent the previously described differentiation protocols and were stained for calcium deposition (Von Kossa), for glycosaminoglycan (GAG) synthesis (Toluidine blue), and for lipidic accumulation (Nile Red) to assess osteogenic, chondrogenic, and adipogenic commitments, respectively. Stainings were performed as previously described. 21,31,32
Western blot analysis
MEFs cultured in different conditions were subjected to lysis in radioimmunoprecipitation assay buffer (BP-115D, Boston Bioproducts, Worcester, MA) containing protease inhibitors (Complete-Mini, Roche Diagnostics). Two-dimensional cultured MEF lysates were used as control protein samples in osteogenic differentiation assays. Cell lysates from these cultures were subjected to NuPAGE (NP0321, Invitrogen), transferred onto a polyvinylidene
Real-time reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction
mRNA was isolated from MEFs using Trizol (15596-026, Invitrogen), cultured in RAD16-I, and cultured in two dimensions (controls) at days 3, 7, 11, and 15. After degradation of cellular DNA, first-strand cDNA was synthesized from the mRNA using Taqman Reverse Transcriptase (N808-0234, Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA). Real-time reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) reactions were performed in SYBR green PCR master mix (204143) using commercial primers of Sox9 (QT00163765), Runx2 (QT00102193), Col2a1 (QT01055523), Col1a1 (QT00162204) and Col1a2 (QT01055572) (all from Qiagen, Valencia, CA). Relative gene fold variations were all determined according to the 2−ΔΔCt method using the ribosomal unit 18S (QT01036875, Qiagen) as a housekeeping gene.
Reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction
mRNA was isolated from MEFs using Trizol (15596-026, Invitrogen), cultured in RAD16-I, and cultured in two dimensions (controls), at days 3, 7, 11, and 15. After degradation of cellular DNA, 0.2 μg of mRNA was retrotranscribed with Omniscript (205111, Qiagen). The cDNA obtained was amplified using PCR (95°C 2 min, 35 cycles of 95°C 20 s, 58°C 30 s, and 68°C 30 s) using Accuprime Pfx (12344-024, Invitrogen). The primers were kindly provided by Dr David Shaywitz, Harvard University (forward: 5’-CATGTACTCTTTCTTGCTGG-3’; reverse: 5’-GGTCTCG GGAAAGCAGTGGC-3’).
GAG quantification
GAGs were quantified using 1,9-dimethyl-dimethylene blue (DMMB; 23481-50-7, Polysciences, Warrington, PA). The samples were treated overnight with pronase at 60ºC and centrifuged at 14,000 g. The supernatant (40 μL) was incubated with 360 μL of a solution of DMMB (0.16% DMMB in 0.2% formic acid [251364, Sigma-Aldrich] with 2.5 mg/mL sodium formate [71541, Sigma-Aldrich]; pH 3.5) and read in a spectrophotometer with visible light (λ = 535 nm).33 Standards for chondroitin 6 sulfate from shark cartilage (27043, Sigma-Aldrich) were used to prepare a calibration curve with values between 0 and 100 μg/mL.
Immunostaining of MEFs cultured in RAD16-I
MEFs cultured in RAD16-I for 7 to 15 days with FM were fixed with 2% PFA and washed twice with PBS 1 × prepared from 10 × PBS (EM-6508, VWR). Endogenous peroxidase activity was blocked with 0.3% hydrogen peroxide in PBS Tween 20 at room temperature for 30 min. Samples were blocked with 20% (v/v) FBS in PBS with 0.1% (v/v) Triton X-100 (T-9284, Sigma-Aldrich) and 1% (v/v) dimethyl sulfoxide (O81-1, Honeywell Burdick and Jackson, Morristown, NJ). Incubation with the indicated primary antibodies was performed overnight at 4°C. After a 24-h washing step, samples were incubated overnight at 4°C with the secondary HRP-conjugated antibodies. Localization of proteins was finally revealed by reaction with diaminobenzidene (DAB) substrate (1718906, Roche Diagnostics).
Brachyury in situ hybridization
MEF cultures in RAD16-I were fixed at days 7, 11, and 15. In situ hybridization was performed whole mount and onto 14-μm slices of the tissue-like cell mass obtained after culturing. Slices were obtained by cryosectioning of the cell mass with a Leica CM 3050 S cryostat using optimal cutting temperature compound (Tissue-tek, VWR) as freezing support. The DNA probe used for the in situ hybridization was synthesized with the PCR DIG probe synthesis kit (11636090910, Roche Diagnostics) using primers kindly provided by D. Shaywitz (forward primer: CATGTACTCTTTCTTGCTGG; reverse primer: GGTCTCGGGAAAGCAGTGGC). The in situ hybridization was performed following the company's instructions for embryos and for tissue sections. After hybridization of the DIG-labeled probe, samples were immunostained for DIG using anti-DIG sheep antibody and anti-sheep HRP-conjugated antibody. Reaction with DAB substrate (1718906, Roche Diagnostics) showed the localization of brachyury mRNA.
Results
Fibroblasts suffer a morphogenetic process when cultured in RAD16-I
To understand the influence of the biomechanical and biological environments on the behavior of fibroblasts in the peptidic nanofiber scaffold RAD16-I, we varied the concentration of peptide used to form the scaffold (0.25-0.5%) and the concentration of FBS (2-15%) added to the medium (Fig. 1B). We observed that, when cultured in 0.25% RAD16-I and 15% FBS, fibroblasts engage in a morphogenetic process that renders a compact cell mass with a central axis and two thick parallel structures at each side of the central line (Fig. 1C). During the first 1 to 2 days in culture, the cells contracted the scaffold from a disk shape to a much smaller, flat, dense disk. Four to 6 days after encapsulation, the edge of the disk continued the contraction, compacting its perimeter and turning it into a wheel-like shape with a semicircular cross-section or dome shape. Next, two diametrically opposite zones at the edge of the wheel or dome started actively contracting inward, converging at the center and compressing both sides. As a consequence, the compaction of the cell masses from each side of the dome caused a merging zone that formed a “middle line.” This process seemed to elongate the body along the axis, producing two large, dense paraxial structures, which resulted in a 3D bilateral assembly 11 to 15 days after encapsulation (Fig. 1C). At this point, the cell mass had gone through the main morphological changes. For better understanding, we show a schematic representation suggesting the main morphological process that the system undergoes to develop into a 3D bilateral structure (Fig. 1D). Optical cross-sections at two time points suggested the formation of an internal cavity as a result of this morphogenetic process (Fig. 1C). The final shape presents bilateral symmetry
Proliferation is required to complete the morphogenetic changes
To further understand this phenomenon, fibroblasts, cultured as explained above, were treated with staurosporine (an inhibitor of the protein kinase C, that arrests cells in G1). Staurosporine clearly abrogated the development of the 3D bilateral structure. Figure 1E shows that no evident incorporation of BrdU was detected in staurosporine-treated samples, whereas control samples exhibited high proliferation in the outermost circle of the cell mass. Moreover, a dose-response inhibitory effect on the 3D bilateral structure development can be observed when diluted concentrations of staurosporine are added to the cultures (Fig. 1F). These results indicate that, during this morphogenetic event, the cell density increases not only because of contraction, but also because of proliferation, suggesting that the system needs to reach a critical cell mass for this phenomenon to occur.
Fibroblasts have multipotentiality and default chondrogenic commitment in RAD16-I
Fibroblasts have been shown to have multipotential capacity to differentiate into mesenchymal lineages.21–30 To further assess the multipotentiality of MEFs, we evaluated the osteogenic, adipogenic, and chondrogenic capacities of fibroblasts cultured in the RAD16-I nanofiber scaffold, in agarose (a non-instructive 3D environment), and in collagen type I (the natural extracellular matrix (ECM) of dermal fibroblasts and bone). We questioned whether these three chemically unrelated matrices promoted the acquisition of mesenchymal potentiality, as observed before in RAD16-I.21 Osteogenic, adipogenic, and chondrogenic phenotypes were assessed according to Von Kossa, Nile red, and toluidine blue staining, respectively. Figure 2H shows that fibroblasts undergo acute osteogenesis in all 3D environments after induction with osteogenic supplements, which the high extracellular deposition of calcium salts indicates (Fig. 2A, D and Supplemental Fig. G–K available online at www.liebertonline.com/ten). Osteogenesis occurred only with the addition of osteogenic supplements, whereas adipogenesis occurred with (not shown) and without adipogenic supplements (Fig. 2C, F, G). Chondrogenesis arose only in the self-assembling peptide scaffolds, with (Supplemental Fig. C) and without chondrogenic supplements (Fig. 2B, E and Supplemental Fig. F), indicating that there is some relationship between chondrogenesis and the biomechanical and non-instructive characteristics of RAD16-I.
FIG. 2. Multipotencial capacity of mouse embryonic fibroblasts (MEFs). (A–J) Phenotype of MEFs cultured in three-dimensional (3D) self-assembling peptide hydrogel. RAD16-I was assessed under different culture conditions. (A, D) After osteogenic induction, von Kossa staining revealed calcium deposition within the cell cultures. (B, E) Toluidine blue staining of MEFs showed default chondrogenic differentiation in control cultures, without need of any supplements. (C) Adipocytes in non-supplemented cell cultures were detectable by visual inspection. (F, G) Nile red staining stained the neutral lipids of these adipocytes (F, fluorescein filter, green; G, rhodamine filter, red). For space reasons, pictures of differentiation results in 2D-culture vontrols and 3D cultures in agarose and collagen type I systems are presented in the Supplemental Figure, available online at www.liebertonline.com/ten. (H) Osteogenic, chondrogenic, and adipogenic differentiation assays were performed as indicated on MEFs, and three different stainings were used to identify cell commitments: Von Kossa staining was used to identify osteogenic, toludine blue staining for chondrogenic, and Nile red staining for adipogenic differentiations. For reference level of differentiation: − (negative), + (slightly positive), ++ (positive), +++ (highly positive). The table shows that MEFs can acquire osteogenic and adipogenic phenotypes in three dimensions, but only in RAD16-I can they undergo natural chondrogenesis. Color images available online at www.liebertonline.com/ten.
Western blot analysis revealed that the pre-osteogenic transcription factor Runx2 was more upregulated in MEFs cultured without inductive supplements in the nanofiber scaffold RAD16-I than expression levels of the same cells cultured in 2D (Fig. 3A). Then the addition of differentiating supplements caused an upregulation of the expression of Runx2 in 2D cultures, whereas in 3D cultures, Runx2
FIG. 3. Molecular characterization of the mesodermal induction process. (A) Runt-related transcription factor 2 (Runx2) expression was analyzed according to Western blot in mouse embryonic fibroblasts (MEFs) cultured in RAD16-I after the osteogenic differentiation protocol previously described. Two-dimensional (2D) cultures were used as controls. (B) Collagen type II was analyzed according to Western blot in MEFs cultured in flask cultures (2D) after 1 and 15 days in culture and in RAD16-I (3D) after 15 days in culture with fibroblast medium (FM). (C) Glycosaminoglycans (GAGs) from 3D self-assembling peptide cultures of MEF at days 0 and 29 were quantified with 1,9-dimethyl-dimethyleneblue using chondroitin sulfate as the standard. (D) Real-time reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) of Sox9 transcription factor. Total mRNA was isolated from MEFs cultured in RAD16-I with FM and from 2D controls after days 3, 7, 11, and 15. (E) Real-ime RT-PCR of collagen type I, collagen type II, Runx2, and Sox9. Total mRNA was isolated from MEFs cultured in FM for 1, 12, and 17 days and cultured for 12 days in FM followed by 6 days in osteogenic medium. Color images available online at www.liebertonline.com/ten.
Default chondrogenic commitment of MEFs was observed using Western blot analysis of collagen type II (Fig. 3B). Real-time RT-PCR of the transcription factor Sox9 presented a pattern of expression with two peaks of upregulation, one at day 3 and the second at day 11, separated by a downregulation zone at day 7 (Fig. 3D). These changes in expression correlate well with the morphogenic changes previously described. For instance, at day 3, the structure contraction is isotropic, continuing until day 6 (Fig. 1C). At days 7 to 11, the structure starts bilateral contractions, suggesting a dramatic change in the morphogenic process that might affect the expression of Sox9. After several days (11-15 days), the morphogenetic changes finish, and the bilateral structure up-regulates Sox9 again although localized at the paraxial zone (Fig. 4D). In 2D cultures, Sox9 upregulation was less intense, with a gradual increase over time (Fig. 3D). To further understand the gene expression of the 3D system during default chondrogenesis and after osteogenic induction, we evaluated the expression of the transcription factors Runx2 and Sox9, as well as ECM proteins such as collagen type Ia1, collagen type Ia2 and collagen type II using real-time RT-PCR. Results show that, at day 12, when the 3D bilateral structure closes, Sox9, Runx2, and collagen type II are more over-expressed than MEFs cultured in flasks (Fig. 3E). At the same time, the synthesis of collagen type I is strongly down-regulated (Fig. 3E), meaning that MEFs cultured in RAD16-I gradually loose their fibroblastic phenotype (characterized by the synthesis of collagen type I) and become chondrocyte-like cells (expressing collagen type II, Runx2, and high levels of Sox9). Then, 5 to 6 days after osteogenic induction, the expression levels of collagen type II, Runx2, and Sox9 decrease (Fig. 3E). Collagen type II remains constant after 17 days of culture without osteogenic supplements (Fig. 3E), consistent with the Western blots (Fig. 3B) and immunohistochemistry (Fig. 4E). The down-regulation of Sox9 and Runx2 appear to be independent of the presence of osteogenic induction (Fig. 3E). In the presence of osteogenic induction, a slightly greater up-regulation of collagen type I 1a2, but not collagen type I 1a, can be observed than under conditions without differentiating factors (Fig. 3E).
FIG. 4. Morphogenesis correlates with pattern formation. (A) Brachyury immunostaining of mouse embryonic fibroblasts (MEFs) cultured in RAD16-I with fibroblast medium (FM) for 7 and 15 days. Whole-mount immunostaining showed the localization of brachyury expression in the three-dimensional (3D) bilateral structures of 7 and 15 days. Pictures on the right represent a magnification of the zones where brachyury is expressed for better view of the stainings. Brachyury is first expressed in the central axis and then in the paraxial zones. Clusters of expression can be observed at this moment (day 15). (B) In situ hybridization was also performed to observe the localization of brachyury. Totally contracted samples (15 days of culture in FM) were fixed and cryosectioned as indicated. In situ hybridization over a 14-μm slice of the 3D bilateral structure showed that brachyury is expressed in the external paraxial zone. Shortly after closure of the central axis (11 days of culture), the cell mass was fixed. Whole-mount in situ hybridization showed the localization of brachyury within the cell mass. (C–E) Toluidine blue staining and immunostaining for Sox9 and collagen type II were performed on MEFs cultured for 15 days in FM. Asterisks show control samples immunostained using only the secondary horseradish peroxidase–conjugated antibody. These three stainings show that chondrogenesis occurs only in the two paraxial zones next to the symmetrical axis. (F) Finally, we propose a mesodermal commitment and cartilage-like tissue development model in our system based in the molecular markers detected. Color images available online at www.liebertonline.com/ten.
Finally, MEFs synthesized GAGs when cultured in RAD16-I with FM, confirming the default cartilaginous commitment of these fibroblasts (Fig. 3C). Moreover, when we stained the 3D bilateral structures with Toluidine blue for GAGs, two positive zones parallel to the central axis were detected, suggesting the formation of a paraxial cartilage-like tissue (Fig. 4C). These results confirm the presence of a glycosylated proteoglycan that could be, for example, aggrecan or perlecan or a mix of them. Perlecan is more consistent with the appearance of cartilage during early development.40
Pattern formation accompanies symmetry appearance
To provide more insight into the possible patterned chondrogenesis, we studied the expression of brachyury, one of the first mesodermal-specific transcription factors that is expressed in the presumptive notochord and in the early mesoderm.41–43 With different culture times, brachyury stained positive according to immunohistochemistry first (day 7) in the central axis and then (day 15) in the entire paraxial zones of the 3D bilateral structure (Fig. 4A). The expression of brachyury was confirmed using regular RT-PCR (see Supplemental Fig., available online at www.liebertonline.com/ten) and its localization was visualized using in situ hybridization. Probes were prepared with the same primers used for regular RT-PCR, and after the staining, we observed that the brachyury mRNA was mainly expressed at the same zone detected using immunohistochemistry, confirming the expression of this early-organizer transcription factor in the 3D bilateral structures (Fig. 4B). Staining of a cross-section of this structure depicts the clear presence of an internal cavity, observed before in Figure 1, and the expression of brachyury at the external paraxial zone (Fig. 4B).
It is also known that the expression of some set of transcription factors, such as Sox9 precedes organized chondrogenic commitment. Thus, we studied the presence and localization of the transcription factor Sox9, a key transcription factor in early chondrogenesis,44 and immunostaining showed that Sox9 is mainly expressed in the paraxial zones next to the symmetrical axis (Fig. 4D). Finally, the synthesis of the key ECM component of cartilage collagen type II was assessed by immunostaining of the 3D bilateral structures cultured for 15 days in FM. Results showed that collagen type II is also expressed at the paraxial zones next to the central symmetrical axis (Fig. 4E).
Discussion
Fibroblasts are known to be responsible for many regenerating events. A significant example is the regeneration of amputated limbs in amphibians, where fibroblasts generate a set of undifferentiated cells called a blastema that is capable of proliferating and rebuilding the new limb.5–9 Previously, fibroblasts cultured in vitro have also shown multipotential capacity21,30 and have reproduced the mesenchymal condensation in micromass cultures.45,46 Nevertheless, it is still not clear what mechanism drives fibroblasts to this multipotential state and which is the exact phenotype of these undifferentiated fibroblats.6,7 We hypothesize that the biomechanical and non-instructive properties of their environment are key for fibroblasts to have the ability to acquire a less differentiated phenotype that allows them to render most of the cell types of the mesodermal germ line.
Our work suggests that any 3D environment, under the culture conditions tested, and regardless of its chemical nature (self-assembling peptide nanofiber, polysaccharide, or protein matrix), is sufficient to promote dedifferentiation of MEFs into a multipotent mesenchymal progenitor-like cell (Fig. 2). This opens the possibility that the cells “sense” the environment, reprogramming them into a multipotent progenitor. Osteogenic commitment of this progenitor cell in 3D environments occurs only after an osteogenic differentiation protocol, which is evidenced by the deposition of Ca2+ (Fig. 2A, D) and the expression of Runx2 (Fig. 3A) (also known as
For instance, these fibroblasts undergo spontaneous adipogenesis in three dimensions (Fig. 2C, F, G), but only in the self-assembling peptide do MEFs begin a default chondrogenic differentiation process, presumably by creating a special cell microenvironment (Fig. 2B, E, 4C). This could be due to the chemical differences between these three scaffolds. The polysacharide (agarose) has shown low interaction with fibroblasts, as well as poor contracting capacity; cells adopt a spherical shape and have little movement inside the scaffold (Supplemental Fig.). Instead, collagen type I is the natural ECM component of the dermis and bone, ensuring high interaction between the cells and the matrix. Furthermore, this material could be instructive in guiding embryonic fibroblasts into these lineages, preventing them from spontaneous differentiation into a chondrogenic lineage (Fig. 2H). Finally, viscoelastic studies with RAD16-I (at different concentrations) over the years have shown that RAD16-I peptide concentrations between 1.7 and 2.8 mg/mL have a G’ (elastic modulus) of 120 and 400 Pa, respectively. In our system, we used final peptide concentrations of approximately 2.5 mg/mL, with a G’ close to 370 Pa, a similar G’ to that of extracellular collagen type I matrices, suggesting that the microenvironment in RAD16-I gels is mechanically similar to the natural ECM of fibroblasts. Therefore, because self-assembling peptide scaffolds lack inherent instructive capacity and have the same biomechanical properties as natural fibroblast ECMs, the default chondrogenesis here described could mean that mouse embryonic fibroblasts can naturally undergo chondrogenic lineage differentiation under the mentioned culture conditions (Fig. 2H). Not only does the self-assembling peptide allow spontaneous chondrogenesis, but it also promotes, under certain conditions, a unique in vitro cellular self-organization that resembles early embryonic stages (Fig. 1C). Furthermore, similar to what has been observed in animal development, the progression of this morphogenesis is dependent on proliferation, as evidenced by the effects of staurosporine on system contraction (Fig. 1E, F). It was also noticed that less initial concentration of MEFs (5 × 105 cells/mL) within the RAD16-I resulted in three fold the contraction time of the cell mass and failed to render bilaterality (results not shown). These results indicate that proliferation seems to have a close relationship with the spontaneous chondrogenic differentiation of MEFs, similar to the relationship between embryonic mesenchymal condensation and chondrogenesis within the pre-skeletal tissue. Altogether, as a consequence of the biomechanical and non-instructive properties of RAD16-I scaffolds, we can speculate that the contraction produced during the morphogenetic process could reproduce a mesenchymal condensation phenomenon that explains the default chondrogenic pathway. Hence, the localized natural chondrogenic induction could be the result of mesenchymal condensation and differentiation under the control of an organized process that directs tissue-like patterning. This is a significant difference from the mesenchymal potential of fibroblasts in high-density micromass cultures, because in these cultures, although fibroblasts reproduce mesenchymal condensation and show default chondrogenic commitment, no self-organization is observed.45,46
We have also showed, using immunohistochemistry and in situ hybridization, that the expression of brachyury, and its localization in this system, is highly related to the formation of the 3D bilaterality (Fig. 4A, B). First, brachyury is expressed in a mid-line zone of the structure, to further spread to both sides of the central axis, suggesting that mesodermal commitment continues advancing toward both sides of the cell mass.
The expression of Sox9 and the synthesis of collagen type II and GAGs also indicated tpontaneous chondrogenesis during this morphogenic development (Fig. 3C, D and 4C–E). Sox9, Runx2, and collagen type II, like brachyury, showed a profile of expression strongly related to morphogenic development, although it remains unknown how the morphological changes proceeded as function of the expression of these genes. Loss-of-function experiments would elucidate the exact relationship between gene expression and the morphogenic process. Sox9 was strongly over-expressed at two time-points during the morphogenetic event related to physical changes: strong isotropic contraction (day 3) and closure of the 3D bilaterality (day 11). The over-expression of Sox9 could be explained as a requirement for the cells to condense, as happens in mesenchymal condensation. Then, after closure of the cellular structure, the expression of Sox9 is upregulated again and correlates with the synthesis of collagen type II, meaning that, at this moment, chondrogenesis is taking place. Runx2 and Collagen type II expression levels are upregulated after closure of the structure and are maintained thereafter.
From the mechanical point of view, from the experiments with different concentrations of RAD16-I (Fig. 1B), it seems clear that the biomechanics in early stages govern the process, at least in the first days of isotropic contraction, when cells form a network and contract the system. It is likely that, at early stages of this phenomenon, some genetic programs start taking control of the evolution of the system. At the time when the lateral contractions start to happen, some genetic programs are already “ruling” the process. We are now focusing on early organizer genes to see whether they are co-localized where and when bilateral contractions take place.
Altogether, we observed that the system undergoes organized contraction, developing into a bilateral shape structure
In conclusion, the system we described here can be used to culture cells carrying specific mutations or transgenic genes and to obtain 3D bilateral structures that recreate certain morphogenetic processes without the use of pregnant females and their embryos. In future work, other cell sources such as dermal fibroblasts from amphibians and other mammals, including adult humans, will be tested to see whether this particular self-organization phenomenon is common in other metazoans.
Acknowledgments
We gratefully acknowledge our colleagues Kelly Blackburn, Alice Chen, Roger Kamm, Alan Grodzinsky, Hayman Hartman, Hans Jörg Meisel, Jaime Rivera, and Angelo Cardoso for helpful discussions and suggestions during the development and writing of this work. We are indebted to David Shaywitz and the Department of Cellular Molecular Biology at Harvard University for providing brachyury primers. We thank Nicky Watson and the microscopy facilities in the Whitehead Institute for the excellent technical assistance in sectioning. We thank the Catalan Government for the pre-doctoral fellowships 2005 BE 00178 and 2005 FI 00864 to L.Q., and to IQS for the pre-doctoral fellowship to E.G. This work was supported by Grant NIH 1-ROI-EB003805-01A1 and award 1098SF from TRM, Universität Leipzig, Germany, to C.E.S.
References
- 1 Pseudoplasmodium formation and organization of Dictyostelium discoideumJ Elisha Mitchell Sci Soc562411940.
1. Raper, K.B. Pseudoplasmodium formation and organization of Dictyostelium discoideum. J Elisha Mitchell Sci Soc 56, 241, 1940. Google Scholar - 2 Surface glycoprotein, gp24, involved in early adhesion of Dictyostelium discoideumDev Biol1212771987.
2. Knecht, D.A., Fuller, D.L. and Loomis, W.F. Surface glycoprotein, gp24, involved in early adhesion of Dictyostelium discoideum. Dev Biol 121, 277, 1987. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 3 Morphogenesis in the family Volvocaceae: different tactics for turning an embryo right-side outProtist1574452006.
3. Hallmann, A. Morphogenesis in the family Volvocaceae: different tactics for turning an embryo right-side out. Protist 157, 445, 2006. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 4 Evolution of individuality during the transition from unicellular to multicellular lifeProc Natl Acad Sci U S A104 Suppl 186132007.
4. Michod, R.E. Evolution of individuality during the transition from unicellular to multicellular life. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 104 Suppl 1, 8613, 2007. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 5 Ferretti PGéraudie J.The tetrapod limbCellular and Molecular Basis of Regeneration: From Invertebrates to HumansChichester, UKJohn Wiley & Sons, Ltd.1998187205.
5. Gardiner, D.M. and Bryant, S.V. The tetrapod limb. In: Ferretti P, and Géraudie J. Cellular and Molecular Basis of Regeneration: From Invertebrates to Humans Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons, Ltd., 1998, pp. 187-205. Google Scholar - 6 A stepwise model system for limb regenerationDev Biol2701352004.
6. Endo, T., Bryant, S.V. and Gardiner, D.M. A stepwise model system for limb regeneration. Dev Biol 270, 135, 2004. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 7 Appendage regeneration in adult vertebrates and implications for regenerative medicineScience31019192005.
7. Brockes, J.P. and Kumar, A. Appendage regeneration in adult vertebrates and implications for regenerative medicine. Science 310, 1919, 2005. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 8 Nerve dependency of regeneration: the role of distal-less and FGF signaling in amphibian limb regenerationDevelopment12234871996.
8. Mullen, L.M., Bryant, S.V., Torok, M.A., Blumberg, B. and Gardiner, D.M. Nerve dependency of regeneration: the role of distal-less and FGF signaling in amphibian limb regeneration. Development 122, 3487, 1996. Medline, Google Scholar - 9 Nerve-blastema interactions induce fibroblast growth factor-1 release during limb regeneration in Pleurodeles waltlDev Growth Differ39151997.
9. Zenjari, C., Boilly, B., Hondermarck, H. and Boilly-Marer, Y. Nerve-blastema interactions induce fibroblast growth factor-1 release during limb regeneration in Pleurodeles waltl. Dev Growth Differ 39, 15, 1997. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 10 Macrophage recruitment during limb development and wound healing in the embryonic and fetal mouseJ Cell Sci10711591994.
10. Hopkinson-Woolley, J., Hughes, D., Gordon, S. and Martin, P. Macrophage recruitment during limb development and wound healing in the embryonic and fetal mouse. J Cell Sci 107, 1159, 1994. Medline, Google Scholar - 11 Self-complementary oligopeptide matrices support mammalian cell attachmentBiomaterials1613851995.
11. Zhang, S., Holmes, T.C., DiPersio, C.M., Hynes, R.O., Su, X. and Rich, A. Self-complementary oligopeptide matrices support mammalian cell attachment. Biomaterials 16, 1385, 1995. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 12 Direct conversion of an oligopeptide from a beta-sheet to an alpha-helix: a model for amyloid formationProc Natl Acad Sci U S A94231997.
12. Zhang, S. and Rich, A. Direct conversion of an oligopeptide from a beta-sheet to an alpha-helix: a model for amyloid formation. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 94, 23, 1997. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 13 Self-assembling peptide hydrogel fosters chondrocyte extracellular matrix production and cell division: implications for cartilage tissue repairProc Natl Acad Sci U S A9999962002.
13. Kisiday, J., Jin, M., Kurz, B., Hung, H., Semino, C., Zhang, S. and Grodzinsky, A.J. Self-assembling peptide hydrogel fosters chondrocyte extracellular matrix production and cell division: implications for cartilage tissue repair. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 99, 9996, 2002. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 14 Functional differentiation of hepatocyte-like spheroid structures from putative liver progenitor cells in three-dimensional peptide scaffoldsDifferentiation712622003.
14. Semino, C.E., Merok, J.R., Crane, G.G., Panagiotakos, G. and Zhang, S. Functional differentiation of hepatocyte-like spheroid structures from putative liver progenitor cells in three-dimensional peptide scaffolds. Differentiation 71, 262, 2003. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 15 Entrapment of migrating hippocampal neural cells in three-dimensional peptide nanofiber scaffoldTissue Eng106432004.
15. Semino, C.E., Kasahara, J., Hayashi, Y. and Zhang, S. Entrapment of migrating hippocampal neural cells in three-dimensional peptide nanofiber scaffold. Tissue Eng 10, 643, 2004. Link, Google Scholar - 16 Endothelial cells promote cardiac myocyte survival and spatial reorganization: implications for cardiac regenerationCirculation1109622004.
16. Narmoneva, D.A., Vukmirovic, R., Davis, M.E., Kamm, R.D. and Lee, R.T. Endothelial cells promote cardiac myocyte survival and spatial reorganization: implications for cardiac regeneration. Circulation 110, 962, 2004. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 17 The effect of functionalized self-assembling peptide scaffolds on human aortic endothelial cell functionBiomaterials2633412005.
17. Genove, E., Shen, C., Zhang, S. and Semino, C.E. The effect of functionalized self-assembling peptide scaffolds on human aortic endothelial cell function. Biomaterials 26, 3341, 2005. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 18 The enhancement of osteoblast growth and differentiation in vitro on a peptide hydrogel-polyHIPE polymer hybrid materialBiomaterials2651982005.
18. Bokhari, M.A., Akay, G., Zhang, S. and Birch, M.A. The enhancement of osteoblast growth and differentiation in vitro on a peptide hydrogel-polyHIPE polymer hybrid material. Biomaterials 26, 5198, 2005. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 19 ECM and cell surface proteolysis: regulating cellular ecologyCell914391997.
19. Werb, Z. ECM and cell surface proteolysis: regulating cellular ecology. Cell 91, 439, 1997. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 20 Matrix metalloproteinase activity correlates with blastema formation in the regenerating MRL mouse ear hole modelDev Dyn2263772003.
20. Gourevitch, D., Clark, L., Chen, P., Seitz, A., Samulewicz, S.J. and Heber-Katz, E. Matrix metalloproteinase activity correlates with blastema formation in the regenerating MRL mouse ear hole model. Dev Dyn 226, 377, 2003. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 21 Osteogenic differentiation of mouse embryonic stem cells and mouse embryonic fibroblasts in a three-dimensional self-assembling peptide scaffoldTissue Eng1222152006.
21. Garreta, E., Genove, E., Borros, S. and Semino, C.E. Osteogenic differentiation of mouse embryonic stem cells and mouse embryonic fibroblasts in a three-dimensional self-assembling peptide scaffold. Tissue Eng 12, 2215, 2006. Link, Google Scholar - 22 Osf2/Cbfa1: a transcriptional activator of osteoblast differentiationCell897471997.
22. Ducy, P., Zhang, R., Geoffroy, V., Ridall, A.L. and Karsenty, G. Osf2/Cbfa1: a transcriptional activator of osteoblast differentiation. Cell 89, 747, 1997. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 23 Molecular mechanisms mediating proliferation/differentiation interrelationships during progressive development of the osteoblast phenotypeEndocr Rev144241993.
23. Stein, G.S. and Lian, J.B. Molecular mechanisms mediating proliferation/differentiation interrelationships during progressive development of the osteoblast phenotype. Endocr Rev 14, 424, 1993. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 24 Osteogenic differentiation of purified, culture-expanded human mesenchymal stem cells in vitroJ Cell Biochem642951997.
24. Jaiswal, N., Haynesworth, S.E., Caplan, A.I. and Bruder, S.P. Osteogenic differentiation of purified, culture-expanded human mesenchymal stem cells in vitro. J Cell Biochem 64, 295, 1997. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 25 Multilineage potential of adult human mesenchymal stem cellsScience2841431999.
25. Pittenger, M.F., Mackay, A.M., Beck, S.C., Jaiswal, R.K., Douglas, R., Mosca, J.D., Moorman, M.A., Simonetti, D.W., Craig, S. and Marshak, D.R. Multilineage potential of adult human mesenchymal stem cells. Science 284, 143, 1999. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 26 Differentiation of osteoblasts and in vitro bone formation from murine embryonic stem cellsTissue Eng7892001.
26. Buttery, L.D., Bourne, S., Xynos, J.D., Wood, H., Hughes, F.J., Hughes, S.P., Episkopou, V. and Polak, J.M. Differentiation of osteoblasts and in vitro bone formation from murine embryonic stem cells. Tissue Eng 7, 89, 2001. Link, Google Scholar - 27 Differentiation of osteoblasts from murine embryonic stem cells by overexpression of the transcriptional factor osterixTissue Eng1014562004.
27. Tai, G., Polak, J.M., Bishop, A.E., Christodoulou, I. and Buttery, L.D. Differentiation of osteoblasts from murine embryonic stem cells by overexpression of the transcriptional factor osterix. Tissue Eng 10, 1456, 2004. Link, Google Scholar - 28 In vitro differentiation and in vivo mineralization of osteogenic cells derived from human embryonic stem cellsTissue Eng1015182004.
28. Bielby, R.C., Boccaccini, A.R., Polak, J.M. and Buttery, L.D. In vitro differentiation and in vivo mineralization of osteogenic cells derived from human embryonic stem cells. Tissue Eng 10, 1518, 2004. Link, Google Scholar - 29 Osteogenic differentiation within intact human embryoid bodies result in a marked increase in osteocalcin secretion after 12 days of in vitro culture, and formation of morphologically distinct nodule-like structuresTissue Cell373252005.
29. Cao, T., Heng, B.C., Ye, C.P., Liu, H., Toh, W.S., Robson, P., Li, P., Hong, Y.H. and Stanton, L.W. Osteogenic differentiation within intact human embryoid bodies result in a marked increase in osteocalcin secretion after 12 days of in vitro culture, and formation of morphologically distinct nodule-like structures. Tissue Cell 37, 325, 2005. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 30 Primary mouse embryonic fibroblasts: a model of mesenchymal cartilage formationJ Cell Physiol2003272004.
30. Lengner, C.J., Lepper, C., van Wijnen, A.J., Stein, J.L., Stein, G.S. and Lian, J.B. Primary mouse embryonic fibroblasts: a model of mesenchymal cartilage formation. J Cell Physiol 200, 327, 2004. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 31 A quick, reliable, and automated method for fat cell sizingJ Lipid Res4417952003.
31. Tchoukalova, Y.D., Harteneck, D.A., Karwoski, R.A., Tarara, J. and Jensen, M.D. A quick, reliable, and automated method for fat cell sizing. J Lipid Res 44, 1795, 2003. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 32 Toluidine blue staining of cartilage proteoglycan subunitsActa Histochem611271978.
32. Geyer, G. and Linss, W. Toluidine blue staining of cartilage proteoglycan subunits. Acta Histochem 61, 127, 1978. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 33 Induction of chondro-, osteo- and adipogenesis in embryonic stem cells by bone morphogenetic protein-2: effect of cofactors on differentiating lineagesBMC Dev Biol512005.
33. zur Nieden, N.I., Kempka, G., Rancourt, D.E. and Ahr, H.J. Induction of chondro-, osteo- and adipogenesis in embryonic stem cells by bone morphogenetic protein-2: effect of cofactors on differentiating lineages. BMC Dev Biol 5, 1, 2005. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 34 Regulation of fibroblast-mediated collagen gel contraction by platelet-derived growth factor, interleukin-1 alpha and transforming growth factor-beta 1J Cell Sci102 ( Pt 2)3151992.
34. Tingstrom, A., Heldin, C.H., and Rubin, K. Regulation of fibroblast-mediated collagen gel contraction by platelet-derived growth factor, interleukin-1 alpha and transforming growth factor-beta 1. J Cell Sci 102 ( Pt 2), 315, 1992. Medline, Google Scholar - 35 Smad3 mediates the TGF-beta-induced contraction of type I collagen gels by mouse embryo fibroblastsCell Motil Cytoskeleton542482003.
35. Liu, X., Wen, F.Q., Kobayashi, T., Abe, S., Fang, Q., Piek, E., Bottinger, E.P., Roberts, A.B., and Rennard, S.I. Smad3 mediates the TGF-beta-induced contraction of type I collagen gels by mouse embryo fibroblasts. Cell Motil Cytoskeleton 54, 248, 2003. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 36 Platelet-derived growth factor A modulates limb chondrogenesis both in vivo and in vitroMech Dev94132000.
36. Ataliotis, P. Platelet-derived growth factor A modulates limb chondrogenesis both in vivo and in vitro. Mech Dev 94, 13, 2000. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 37 The adaptive remodeling of condylar cartilage—a transition from chondrogenesis to osteogenesisJ Dent Res846912005.
37. Shen, G. and Darendeliler, M.A. The adaptive remodeling of condylar cartilage—a transition from chondrogenesis to osteogenesis. J Dent Res 84, 691, 2005. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 38 The control of chondrogenesisJ Cell Biochem97332006.
38. Goldring, M.B., Tsuchimochi, K. and Ijiri, K. The control of chondrogenesis. J Cell Biochem 97, 33, 2006. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 39 Bone developmentAnnu Rev Cell Dev Biol161912000.
39. Olsen, B.R., Reginato, A.M. and Wang, W. Bone development. Annu Rev Cell Dev Biol 16, 191, 2000. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 40 Expression of the heparan sulfate proteoglycan, perlecan, during mouse embryogenesis and perlecan chondrogenic activity in vitroJ Cell Biol14511031999.
40. French, M.M., Smith, S.E., Akanbi, K., Sanford, T., Hecht, J., Farach-Carson, M.C. and Carson, D.D. Expression of the heparan sulfate proteoglycan, perlecan, during mouse embryogenesis and perlecan chondrogenic activity in vitro. J Cell Biol 145, 1103, 1999. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 41 Brachyury, the blastopore and the evolution of the mesodermBioessays237882001.
41. Technau, U. Brachyury, the blastopore and the evolution of the mesoderm. Bioessays 23, 788, 2001. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 42 Structure and function of the notochord: an essential organ for chordate developmentDevelopment13225032005.
42. Stemple, D.L. Structure and function of the notochord: an essential organ for chordate development. Development 132, 2503, 2005. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 43 The chick Brachyury gene: developmental expression pattern and response to axial induction by localized activinDev Biol1684061995.
43. Kispert, A., Ortner, H., Cooke, J. and Herrmann, B.G. The chick Brachyury gene: developmental expression pattern and response to axial induction by localized activin. Dev Biol 168, 406, 1995. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 44 The role of TGFbetas and Sox9 during limb chondrogenesisCurr Opin Cell Biol187232006.
44. Kawakami, Y., Rodriguez-Leon, J. and Belmonte, J.C. The role of TGFbetas and Sox9 during limb chondrogenesis. Curr Opin Cell Biol 18, 723, 2006. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 45 Chondrogenic differentiation of murine C3H10T1/2 multipotential mesenchymal cells: I. Stimulation by bone morphogenetic protein-2 in high-density micromass culturesDifferentiation64671999.
45. Denker, A.E., Haas, A.R., Nicoll, S.B. and Tuan, R.S. Chondrogenic differentiation of murine C3H10T1/2 multipotential mesenchymal cells: I. Stimulation by bone morphogenetic protein-2 in high-density micromass cultures. Differentiation 64, 67, 1999. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar - 46 Ribozyme-mediated perlecan knockdown impairs chondrogenic differentiation of C3H10T1/2 fibroblastsDifferentiation74532006.
46. Gomes, R.R.J., Joshi, S.S., Farach-Carson, M.C. and Carson, D.D. Ribozyme-mediated perlecan knockdown impairs chondrogenic differentiation of C3H10T1/2 fibroblasts. Differentiation 74, 53, 2006. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar
